This Month in 2006 | BIOP: CONDIT DAM REMOVAL HAS MORE BENEFITS THAN NEGATIVES
NOAA Fisheries says the long-term benefits for protected Columbia River basin salmon and steelhead outweigh what will be short-term negative effects resulting from the proposed removal of Condit Dam on Washington’s White Salmon River.
That assessment was delivered Oct. 12 in the form of a NOAA biological opinion on the effects of the proposed dam removal. There are 13 basin salmon and steelhead stocks listed under the Endangered Species Act that could be potentially affected by the proposed “action.”
“NMFS has determined that the proposed action is not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of these species, or destroy or adversely modify designated critical habitat,” according to a BiOp cover letter signed by D. Robert Lohn, NOAA’s Northwest Region administrator. Nor will it jeopardize the chance of recovery of any of the listed species, the agency surmises.
“Firstly, the adverse effects on listed species will be relatively short term and there will be a long term benefit for at least two of the listed species from restoring access to historical habitat above Condit Dam,” according to the BiOp.
“Secondly, currently occupied habitat will be restored in the long term and maintained by natural channel forming processes which will restore the conservation value of designated critical habitat in the lower White Salmon River,” the BiOp says.
The “dominant” negative effect would be the sudden release of large volumes of sediment into the lower river that have been deposited in the dam’s reservoir, Northwestern Lake, over time.
The hydro project, owned by PacifiCorp, was built in 1913. The White Salmon River in south-central Washington’s Skamania and Klickitat counties empties into the Columbia near the town of White Salmon upstream of Bonneville Dam.
The Condit powerhouse is located on the Big White Salmon River at river mile 2.2 and the dam is located at mile 3.3. They are connected by a 1.1-mile bypass reach. A fish ladder was included in the initial dam construction but was was destroyed by a flood in 1918 and never replaced.
Initial sediment releases would likely be lethal to any salmon in the lower White Salmon River, most likely Lower Columbia River chinook. But trapping and holding fish found in the lower river prior to the suggested October 2008 dam removal would preserve the next generation of the fish and reduce mortality, NOAA says. Most steelhead now spawning in the river’s lower reaches are believed to be non-listed strays, the BiOp says.
The proposed dam removal is expected to have long-term benefits for the four species to be most impacted — Mid-Columbia steelhead, Lower Columbia chinook and coho and Columbia River chum salmon. The removal would allow access to about 14 miles of chinook and 33 miles of steelhead habitat that has been blocked since the dam was built. The listed chinook and steelhead stocks are the two species that would benefit most with the reopening of upstream habitat.
Additionally, “the restoration of unregulated flows through the lower White Salmon River should fully restore, over time, the spawning, rearing and migration habitat to its full potential, and contribute to the recovery” of the four species, the BiOp says. The chum and coho would gain the most benefit there.
Other listed species, migrating adults and juveniles, that pass by the mouth of the river “may encounter minor and very brief (up to 1 day) pulses of sediment in the Columbia River mixing zone during their upstream and downstream migration in the spring and early summer of 2009, and possibly by 2010, released by storm runoff events in the White Salmon Basin,” the BiOp says.
“… but it is not to result in injury or delayed migration,” according to the BiOp.
Historic dam operations have served to degrade the lower river habitat for spawning, rearing and migration by increasing water temperatures and interrupting channel forming processes such as flow, gravel and the establishment of large woody debris. Breaching will further degrade that habitat for some time but it should rebuild.
“Within a few years, the quality of spawning, rearing and migration habitat in the lower river will improve significantly as fines are flushed out, gravel and LWD migrate downstream, and invertebrate prey recolonnize the substrate,” the BiOp says.
Privately owned hydro projects such as Condit must be licensed by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. The long-term license for Condit expired in 1993 and it has been operated since on a series of one-year licenses.
FERC issued a Final Environmental Impact Statement in October 1996 recommending PacifiCorp’s proposed operating conditions, but with modifications recommended by FERC staff. The preferred alternative included the construction and operation of both upstream and downstream fish passage facilities and several other aquatic resource-related measures.
PacifiCorp concluded that the new license conditions proposed in the 1996 FEIS would render the Condit Project uneconomic to operate, and in 1997 petitioned FERC to suspend the proceeding and entered into discussions with license interveners regarding potential settlement.
“A new license (to operate the dam) was no longer in our interest” under the terms prescribed by FERC, said PacifiCorp spokesman Dave Kvamme.
A settlement was reached in 1999 that called for dam removal. It was filed with FERC, which in 2002 initiated ESA consultation with NOAA. FERC also in 2002 issued a Final Supplemental EIS that describes the decommissioning and removal of the dam as that agency’s preferred alternative.
PacifiCorp has since been working to gain the necessary permits from county, state and federal entities.
“That’s proven to be a difficult process,” Kvamme said. Discussions have been ongoing with local officials, where the proposal has met considerable opposition. PacifiCorp approached FERC to get clarification on just exactly what permits would be required but got a mixed answer, he said. The federal agency’s response said that it has ultimately authority but did not list the permits that it would require.
A certain need is a 401 water quality certification from the state Department of Ecology. Kvamme said that a final state environmental document is now expected in early December and a draft 401 certification is due in January. A final 401 certification could come in June.
“Provided those dates hold up, we could expect a surrender order by next July” from FERC authorizing the dam removal, Kvamme said.
Clean Water Act Section 404 and Rivers and Harbors Act Section 10 permits with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers are also being pursued.
That water quality permit, like the BiOp, could include provisions that drive costs up and make removal les economically favorable for PacifiCorp customers. The BiOp calls for such actions as the fish trapping, erosion control and monitoring.
“I haven’t personally heard anything that’s drawn any serious concern” about the BiOp, Kvamme said, though the company is still evaluating the new document.
“The BiOp is a necessary step in the whole process,” he said. The company would like to push ahead.
“Our purpose is to implement the settlement agreement,” he said.
For more information about Condit Dam go to http://www.pacificorp.com/Article/Article46835.html